Volver al blog

Peter Attia changes his mind on the keto diet and fasting

Plato blanco partido por la mitad: una mitad con huevo frito, aguacate y aceitunas y la otra vacía, sobre fondo terracota

Peter Attia still thinks the keto diet is effective, but he has changed his mind about why it works: he used to believe it was because it lowers insulin, and now he believes it works like many restrictive diets, because it makes it easier to eat less energy. He has also stopped the 7 to 10-day fasts he used to do every quarter, and has growing doubts about metformin and rapamycin.

Attia is a physician, the author of Outlive and one of the most listened-to voices in longevity. In October 2026 he went through, on his podcast, where he has been wrong or has refined his views over the years, guided by an idea he sums up as strong convictions, loosely held.

Keto: it still works, but for a different reason

Three years in strict ketosis

Attia followed a ketogenic diet for three years and says it was probably the time he felt best. It was not light ketosis: his fasting beta-hydroxybutyrate, the ketone body measured in blood, averaged between 1.8 and 2 millimoles throughout. Three years without bread, which is easier said than done.

He gave it up out of fatigue: he was tired of eating so restrictively. What has changed is his explanation of why it works:

"To this day, I still view it as an effective diet. What has changed is my belief as to why it works. I used to believe that the diet worked through insulin suppression. Today, I think the diet works for the same reason many restrictive diets work, which is it makes it easier to control energy intake."

From insulin to energy balance

For years, the most popular explanation for keto was the so-called carbohydrate-insulin model: eating lots of carbohydrates raises insulin, insulin stores fat and, if you lower it, you lose weight even if you eat the same. Attia now sees it the other way round: visceral fat, liver fat and declining insulin sensitivity are the result of excess energy, and high insulin is "along for the ride".

The most cited trials on this were led by Kevin Hall at the US National Institutes of Health, with participants living on a metabolic ward and food tightly controlled:

  • In 2016, switching from a carbohydrate-containing diet to a ketogenic diet with the same calories did not speed up body fat loss; energy expenditure rose only slightly, close to the limit of what can be measured.
  • In 2021, 20 adults ate as much as they wanted for two weeks on a ketogenic diet and two weeks on a low-fat diet. On the low-fat diet they ate about 690 kcal less per day. In other words, in that study keto was not the diet that helped most with eating less.

This fits what Attia says: energy balance is what counts. In practice, the diet that works best is the one that helps you eat what you need, and that varies a lot from person to person.

Why you can gain weight on keto

Someone on keto will have lower insulin, but if they eat more energy than they burn they will not lose weight. As Attia puts it: "You could gain weight on a ketogenic diet if you're out of energy balance." That is why he is now much less dogmatic about the strategy each patient uses to eat less.

The rule that does not change: at least 1.4 g of protein per kilo

What remains non-negotiable for him is protein:

"I really am pretty adamant about people maintaining the right amount of protein. And at a minimum, I want them hitting 1.4 grams per kilogram of body weight."

Whether people achieve it on keto, a low-fat diet or a mostly pescatarian diet matters much less to him than it once did.

What this means in practice

For a 70 kg person, 1.4 g per kilo is about 98 g of protein per day. For reference, EFSA sets the population reference intake for adults at 0.83 g per kilo (about 58 g for the same person), so Attia's minimum is well above the European one. It is his clinical criterion, designed mainly to preserve muscle with age; if you have kidney disease or any doubts, check with your doctor or a dietitian.

Split across three meals, that is about 33 g per meal. A serving of Satislent Food provides 30 g of plant protein (pea, rice and hemp). The basics of what proteins are and how they help our body have their own article.

Prolonged fasting: from 7 to 10 days every quarter to stopping

For about three years, Attia did something fairly extreme: a fast of seven to ten days once a quarter, and a three-day fast in the other two months. He was not trying to lose weight. He was fascinated by the idea that enough nutrient deprivation could trigger enough autophagy to have real health benefits.

Autophagy: why three days

Autophagy is the process by which cells break down and recycle their own old parts. Attia points out that it does not work like a switch: it ramps up gradually, like ketosis, and in humans there is not even a unit to measure it. Still, based on his conversations with experts and animal studies, "somewhere around three days" seemed to be the point where autophagy rose clearly above what you get from exercise.

What happens in the first hours without food, from 12 to 48, is in autophagy: what it is, how to activate it and how many hours of fasting you need.

Why he stopped

Asked why he no longer fasts like that, he says what changed most was "the evidence, but also the cost". One of those costs is lean-mass loss: in a week-long fast you also lose muscle. Today he sees it as something that only pays off for some people.

GLP-1 and calorie restriction: the DR, TR and CR framework

In Outlive, Attia groups every diet into three levers for eating less: calorie restriction (CR, simply eating less), dietary restriction (DR, cutting out foods or food groups, as keto does with carbohydrates) and time restriction (TR, eating within a time window, as in intermittent fasting).

He now believes GLP-1 agonist drugs (such as semaglutide) are tipping the balance towards calorie restriction, because they directly reduce appetite. If you are on one of these treatments, our guide on what to eat on Ozempic covers how to look after protein and fibre, always together with your doctor.

Metformin and rapamycin: why Attia is less convinced

These are two prescription drugs that the longevity world has watched with interest for years. His current position:

  • Metformin: he no longer views it as geroprotective (that is, slowing ageing) in metabolically healthy people.
  • Rapamycin: the animal data are compelling, but human dosing remains unresolved and his doubts have grown.

These are medicines: neither metformin nor rapamycin should be taken without a prescription and medical supervision.

What we take from all this: principles before fine-tuning

The idea that ties all his changes together is prioritising principles, foundations and what you can sustain over marginal optimisation. The same goes for exercise: he has moved away from heavy squats and deadlifts and is less rigid about training. It is a good counterpoint to extreme-protocol longevity, which we discuss in the article on Bryan Johnson and the price of longevity.

Choose the diet you can stick to

If keto, a low-fat diet, the Mediterranean diet or intermittent fasting work mainly because they help you eat the energy you need, the best one is the one you can follow without suffering. Attia gave up keto for exactly that reason: fatigue. If you already follow a keto diet and want a practical option for some days, that is why we made Satislent Keto: here is its new formula.

Get protein and fibre at every meal

The rule Attia does not negotiate is protein. We would add fibre, the other nutrient almost nobody gets enough of: according to the ANIBES study, adults in Spain eat about 12.6 g a day on average, half the 25 g EFSA suggests (more in fibermaxxing). For a 70 kg person, that is about 33 g of protein and about 8 g of fibre in each of three meals. Less heroic than a week-long fast, but you can do it on any ordinary Tuesday.

This article is for information only and does not replace advice from a healthcare professional. Before doing a prolonged fast or taking any medication, talk to your doctor.

Frequently asked questions

Does Peter Attia still do keto?

No. He followed it strictly for three years and stopped because he was tired of eating so restrictively. Even so, he still sees it as an effective diet.

Does the keto diet work through insulin?

Attia no longer thinks so. He now believes it works like many restrictive diets: by making it easier to eat less energy. Kevin Hall's controlled-feeding trials (2016 and 2021) found no fat-loss advantage for keto when calories were equal.

How many days of fasting do you need for autophagy?

Autophagy rises gradually from the first hours without food. According to Attia, clearly higher levels are reached around three days, but there is no practical way to measure it in humans, and he himself has stopped long fasts.

Does Peter Attia take metformin?

He no longer considers metformin geroprotective in metabolically healthy people. It is a prescription drug: if you have questions about it, talk to your doctor.

How much protein does Peter Attia recommend?

At least 1.4 g per kilo of body weight per day. For 70 kg that is about 98 g, above EFSA's reference for adults (0.83 g per kilo).

Sources