Strength training after 40 does not need more sets, it needs the sets you do to count: according to physiotherapist Jeff Cavaliere, you should lower total volume and bring each set closer to muscular failure, leaving at most one or two reps in reserve. He explained it in episode 414 of The Peter Attia Drive, released on 2 November 2026.
Cavaliere is a physiotherapist and the founder of ATHLEAN-X. The episode, almost two hours long, is about how to adapt strength training as we get older. Here we pull out the main ideas, check them against the evidence and turn them into something you can try on Monday.
Why strength matters more from 40 onwards
With age we lose muscle mass, and the first fibres to go are the fast ones (type 2), the ones we use to get up quickly, climb stairs in a hurry or catch ourselves in a fall (review on fibres and sarcopenia). Cavaliere sums it up by saying that what used to cost little now costs more.
The good news is that muscle responds to training at any age. In its 2020 guidelines, the WHO recommends muscle-strengthening activities for all major muscle groups on at least two days a week. That figure is the minimum, not the goal.
Less junk volume, more reps that count
Cavaliere's central argument is that many sets in common routines are what he calls "junk volume": work that tires you and wears your joints but does not stimulate the muscle, because it stays far from real effort. His idea is to lower the number of sets and raise what he calls "productive repetitions".
His comparison is a tyre: every rep is a turn of the wheel, and the turns that do nothing wear the rubber just the same. If you cut those, you can train harder without making recovery harder.
Reps in reserve (RIR), made simple
Reps in reserve (RIR) are the repetitions you could still do at the end of a set if you kept going. It is the simplest way to measure how close to the limit you are:
| RIR | What it means | How it feels |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Mechanical failure: you cannot do another rep with good form | Last rep very slow, about to stop |
| 1 | You could do one more, with effort | Very hard |
| 2-3 | Two or three left | Hard but controlled |
| 4 or more | Four or more left | Comfortable. For Cavaliere it is already junk volume (except in warm-ups) |
Cavaliere thinks we tend to stop short, underestimating by one to three reps how much we have left. That is why he suggests getting as close to failure as the exercise allows. If you find it hard to judge, a practical trick is to film a set and see on which rep the bar speed drops.
Do you have to train to failure? What the evidence says
It is worth separating what the episode says from what the research says, because they are not exactly the same.
- Hypertrophy (building muscle). The Refalo et al. (2023) meta-analysis found no clear advantage of training to failure over stopping earlier. Another study by Refalo et al. (2024), with one leg trained to failure and the other at 1-2 RIR, saw similar quadriceps growth. The meta-regression by Robinson et al. (2024) adds nuance: getting closer to failure has an influence on hypertrophy, though a small one, and almost none on strength gains.
- Fatigue. Failure is associated with more fatigue and slower recovery, a relevant detail when recovering gets harder with age.
- Participants. Those studies were done mostly with young, trained adults. They are not specific to people over 40.
Honest summary: getting to 1-3 RIR works as well as going to the limit every time for almost everyone. What the evidence does support is the part of Cavaliere's proposal about not staying far from real effort.
When to go to failure and when not to
Cavaliere decides on failure according to how safe the exercise is:
- Low-risk exercises (biceps curl, lat pulldown, guided machines): you can go to failure or leave one rep.
- Technical, heavily loaded exercises (squat, deadlift): leave at least one rep in reserve, because form breaks down before the muscle fails and injury risk goes up.
An example routine with fewer sets
This is an example to illustrate the idea, not a prescription. Two or three days a week, full body:
- One pushing exercise (bench press or push-ups): 2 sets of 6 to 10 reps.
- One pulling exercise (row or pulldown): 2 sets of 8 to 12.
- One leg exercise (squat or leg press): 2 sets of 6 to 10, at 1-2 RIR.
- One hip hinge (Romanian deadlift): 2 sets of 6 to 10, at 1-2 RIR.
- One accessory exercise of your choice (curl or lateral raises): 2 sets close to failure.
That is about ten sets per session, compared with twenty or more in many routines. Warm up with light sets first, and add weight only when you reach the top of the rep range with the reserves indicated.
If you have an injury, pain or a medical condition, talk to a doctor or physiotherapist before changing your routine.
Recovery: sleep and food
Cavaliere says it plainly: recovery depends on the training, and also on how you eat and how you sleep. If you do fewer sets but harder ones, each session asks more of your recovery per set, and that is solved in the kitchen and in bed.
- Spread your protein. A good reference is about 20-30 g at each main meal. Our article on plant vs animal protein shows how to get there without meat.
- Sleep. The foods that help you sleep better are covered in this guide.
- An easy meal after training. If you get home with no energy to cook, one serving of Satislent Food has 402 kcal and 30 g of plant protein, plus 7.7 g of fibre and 26 vitamins and minerals. It is a complete food in powder form and it contains gluten, because it has oats. It is not a miracle supplement: it is a meal sorted out when the day has no room for more.
If what you want is mostly protein, we also have Complete Protein. You can see how they differ in this comparison.
Frequently asked questions
How many sets per muscle group a week do you need after 40?
There is no single number. The WHO sets two days of strengthening a week as a minimum, and volume studies show that more sets help up to a point, with diminishing returns. To start, 4 to 6 well-executed sets per muscle group a week is a reasonable starting point.
Is it dangerous to train to failure over 40?
It depends on the exercise. On machines and isolation exercises the risk is low. In squats or deadlifts, fatigue ruins your form, so leave one or two reps in reserve. With pain, injuries or illness, talk to a professional first.
What are reps in reserve?
They are the repetitions you could still do when a set ends. At 0 RIR you reached failure, and at 2 RIR you would have had two left. It is a subjective scale, so at first it is estimated badly and it improves with practice.
Can you build muscle after 40?
Yes. Muscle responds to strength training at any age, although it costs a bit more and recovery is slower. Weekly consistency matters more than any detail of the routine.
Sources
- The Peter Attia Drive (2 November 2026). 414 ‒ Resistance training as we age: exercise selection, training intensity, and much more, with Jeff Cavaliere. Show notes.
- Refalo MC et al. (2023). Influence of Resistance Training Proximity-to-Failure on Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy: A Systematic Review with Meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 53(3), 649-665.
- Refalo MC et al. (2024). Similar muscle hypertrophy following eight weeks of resistance training to momentary muscular failure or with repetitions-in-reserve in resistance-trained individuals. Journal of Sports Sciences.
- Robinson ZP et al. (2024). Exploring the Dose-Response Relationship Between Estimated Resistance Training Proximity to Failure, Strength Gain, and Muscle Hypertrophy: A Series of Meta-Regressions. Sports Medicine, 54(9), 2209-2231.
- WHO (2020). Guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour: at a glance.
- Miljkovic N et al. (2018). The Contributions of Fiber Atrophy, Fiber Loss, In Situ Specific Force, and Voluntary Activation to Weakness in Sarcopenia. The Journals of Gerontology: Series A.
- Satislent Food label: product page.